Sunday, February 28, 2010

My 2 cents on 3 Idiots

I saw 3 idiots over a week ago but maybe the fact it bagged 6 Awards at the Filmfare Awards last night finally prompted me to stop procrastinating & write this! 
I'm not sure why I resisted watching the film for so long, despite being invited by my friends to go see the film on more than one occasion. Maybe I was irked that actors in their thirties & forties were playing engineering students. But it could be some other reason.
Well, what can I say? Most people have already seen it.
There were scenes that made me guffaw (Like Silencer's now famous speech! I was just one step away from literally rolling on the floor!
But there were also emotional scenes that made me cry!
In short, I don't remember when I last saw a film that made me laugh & cry!
This mix of genres was handled rather well, according to me.

And now, about the famous suicide controversy-
Yes I know they they show one student committing suicide & another attempting it. But it's not like they've glorified or glamorized it it any way. Obviously the students who committed suicide in real life were already suicidal, & this just was the final push.
If there really were kids who actually were 'inspired' to commit suicide after watching this film, I would have to say that they were in serious need of help. How could nobody have seen the warning signs? I know it must have been painful for the parents to have their kids take their own life, but to blame a film-maker for it is very irresponsible, not to mention extremely stupid thing to do.

My rating- 4 stars ★★★★ (Out of 5)

My overall verdict- If you haven't seen it yet, go right now!










9 views/opinions shared:

  1. It would be interesting to see if any reviewer suggested how else the movie could have been made.
    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, one of the best movies i have seen with good mix of both laugh and cry.(others being rang de basanti and dil chahata hai) interestingly, ammir khan features in all three. Is it the selection of films or pure luck? I think I know the reason
    ReplyDelete
  3. Agreed, 3 Idiots is an awesome movie, but on watching it for the second time I felt that it was too cliched at some points. What do you say?
    ReplyDelete
  4. I saw the movie too and I give it 3 of 5. A movie that is made to glorify a particular actor is something that I don't like. They have deviated very much from the original plot (which is the book of course). Why does Aamir have to get the girl? Having said that, it is an interesting movie with a good blend of laughter and emotions. It is a good one time watch and poora paisa wasool. :-)
    ReplyDelete
  5. I too think it's much more than just luck ;)
    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree. But it's still good for laughs, na?
    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree. But in front of SRK, I think Aamir is nothing. I have nothing against SRK. But look at the song 'Dard-e-disco' from Om Shanti Om or the entire Billu Barber. So self-glorifying that it's disturbing.
    ReplyDelete
  8. This is my opinion of 3 ididots.. do let me know abt ur view
    http://buffzone.blogspot.com/2010/01/five-point-idiots.html
    ReplyDelete